Ming posted this on the page where I blogged the Mass Shalom, but I thought he posed good questions that might provoke some more general discussion and assistance:
We have been using Mass Shalom for many months now, after switching over from A Chant Mass for the Assembly. The Glory to God chant was a bit touch and go the first couple of times…
I am thinking of trying out some mass settings
– Paul Taylor’s Mass of St Francis (played it through once: also my parents’ parish St Bernadette’s Castle Hill NSW uses it)
I have just bought the following but have not played through them
– Joshua Cowie’s Mass of Mary McKillop (need more than one voice parts to make it work)
– Richard Connolly’s Notre Dame Mass
– Richard Connolly’s Mass of Our Lady Help of Christians
– Maggie Russell’s Mass of Freedom
We have also used the earlier version of Marty Haugen’s Mass of Creation for quite some time.
My own favourite is the (old version of) Bernadette Farrell’s Setting Four in GA (GA 126-132). I looked up Mass of Hope http://www.ocp.org/massofhope and the revised version is much simplified. I miss having this mass sung with a full choir, plus an organ and a keyboard.
I would like to hear from anyone how has used any of the above, or any other mass settings. I just play what has been given to me, but if my wife D’Arne and I can learn some new ones, at least we have the option to try to “sell” them …
We have been with the new settings some years now and maybe it’s time to see what else is out there.
I blogged my impressions of the six settings chosen by the Australian Bishops here but have had reason to review my opinions since. Of the six, Mason’s “Glory and Praise”, Taylor’s “St Francis” and Smith’s “Shalom” (revised by Mason) are all singable, playable and functional for suburban parishes with limited resources, and having played them all in parishes think they work well, although Shalom has always been a difficult one for guitar. I think the other three chosen settings are either for the very talented or Cathedrals. In other words I was too scared to even make backings for them.
I’ve played Haugen’s “Creation” and, while I generally love his songs, I don’t think the Gloria survived the rewrite. Similarly, Maggie Russell’s “Freedom”, has clunks in the revised Gloria that are rather jarring. We have been using it as one of our three settings (with “Glory and Praise” and “St Francis”) but I’d prefer it was retired myself.
If we did look for another setting there is no lack of choice as Ming suggests.
Robinson’s “Mass for Moderns” has been revised, contrary to my ignorant blogging some years ago. It was very popular before the change and is worth looking at again. I’ll put up some backings for sing along purposes soon.
…other worthy possibilities I have blogged already.
The Mayfield Mass
Glendalough Mass
Mass of Love
Mass of St Anne
Mass for a Pilgrim People
Mass of God’s People
Rivers Youth
Rivers
Missa Santa Clara
Pocket Mass (OK that baby is mine and somewhat unlovable)
It may still take years of parishes singing the new masses before any particular setting rises to the top and becomes as ubiquitous as say “Creation” was, but I’d value opinions, ideas, experiences and answers to Ming’s questions. He hints that having to sell a new setting may be a challenge just yet, and I’m sure he’s right as some people are still not over the shock of having to learn a more than one new setting in that first year and may not be ready for any more just yet.